Saturday, April 27, 2019

Mystery Solved: Bushrod Johnson's Division on June 22-23, 1864

I really enjoyed working on this problem.

On June 22, 1864, elements of Bushrod Johnson’s division moved out from reserve behind Field’s and Kershaw’s divisions into the Dimmock Line east of the Lead works in support of Mahone’s troops.  These elements included Wise’s Virginia Brigade, Elliott’s South Carolina Brigade and Ransom’s North Carolina Brigade minus its 49th North Carolina.[1] Around 5 p.m. Bushrod Johnson’s troops advanced southward from the Dimmock Line onto the Johnson farm, passing through harvested wheat tied into sheaves, forming line of battle in the standing wheat to the east, and lying down.[2]  

On June 23, Bushrod Johnson’s division returned to the Dimmock Line about 2 a.m.[3]  At 9 or 10 that morning troops from Bushrod Johnson’s division tramped out to the Johnson farm again and erected breastworks in case II Corps continued its advance westward.[4]  After dark, Bushrod Johnson’s division drew in its skirmish line and the division departed the breastworks it had thrown up just east of the Johnson farmhouse and hoofed it toward Rives Salient, opposite the Federals nearest Petersburg on Jerusalem Plank Road.[5] 

Next, tying up the loose end of Kirkland's (Faribault's) brigade and A. P. Hill's headquarters.

Then: why did Wilcox's brigadiers want him court-martialed for cowardice?

[5] Wiatt, Confederate Chaplain, 182; OR 40, 2:376; Smith Kitchens Diary, June 23, 1864, Winthrop University; Beckham, A Confederate Soldier’s Eloquent War, 92; Clark, NC Regiments, 3:367.

[4] Bushrod Johnson Diary, June 23, 1864, Supplement 7:279; OR 40, 1:761, 2:376, 668-669, 678; Clark, North Carolina Regiments, 3:367; James Carson, The Southern Soldier Boy:  The Experiences of a Confederate Soldier of the 56th North Carolina Regiment During the American Civil War (Driffield, 2010), 34 (left line June 19, 1864, rested 24 hours, then “moved right and worked on some fortifications.”); William Henry Harder Memoir, 525, Tennessee State Archives; Wiatt, Confederate Chaplain, 182; Smith Kitchens Diary, June 22-23, 1864, Winthrop University; Beckham, A Confederate Soldier’s Eloquent War, 92.  Johnson’s brigade remained north of the Appomattox on the right of Pickett’s division.  OR 51, 2:1027.

[3] Wiatt, Confederate Chaplain, 182; Smith Kitchens Diary, June 22-23, 1864, Winthrop University; Beckham, A Confederate Soldier's Eloquent War, 92; Clark, NC Regiments, 3:367.

[2] Wiatt, Confederate Chaplain, 182; Smith Kitchens Diary, June 22-23, 1864, Winthrop University; Beckham, A Confederate Soldier’s Eloquent War, 91-92; Clark, NC Regiments, 3:367. 


[1] Supplement 7:278; OR 40, 1:761; Wiatt, Confederate Chaplain, 182.  Elliott’s brigade also went out to the Dimmock Line.  Smith Kitchens Diary, June 22-23, 1864, Winthrop University; OR 40, 2:376; Mickey Beckham, ed., A Confederate Soldier’s Eloquent War:  The Complete Diary of Samuel Lowry, Enlistment, Hardship, Battles and Death; Yorkville to Columbia, Charleston to Kiawah, to Manasses, to Petersburg, Finally Borne Home by Servant Henry Avery (Charleston, SC, 2008), 91.  Johnson’s Tennessee Brigade and Gracie’s Alabama Brigades did not go out to the Johnson farm because Beauregard had ordered them to the north side of the Appomattox on June 19.  OR 40, 2:668-669, 678; William Henry Harder Memoir, 525, Tennessee State Archives.  Nor did all of Ransom’s Brigade, which had received orders to relieve Colquitt’s brigade of Hoke’s division the previous day but after the 49th North Carolina relieved the pickets of Colquitt’s brigade, the rest of Ransom’s brigade got instructions to support Mahone.  OR 40, 2:678; Clark, North Carolina Regiments, 3:367; Diary of Captain Henry A. Chambers, 205; Diary of Washington L. Dunn, June 21, 1864; The Southern Soldier Boy, 34.



Wednesday, April 17, 2019

Thanks, San Diego Civil War Round Table!



My wife and I were given a pleasant welcome at the San Diego Civil War Round Table's meeting tonight. We are grateful to SDCWRT for accommodating us by postponing my talk from March to April because of the extension in our son's deployment. The subject of the talk was the struggle for the Weldon Railroad in August 1864 around Petersburg.
Fellow authors note:  I sold every book I brought and will be happy to return some day.
Federals Fortifying the Weldon Railroad, August 20, 1864

Saturday, April 13, 2019

Milwaukee and Chicago Civil War Round Tables, May 9 and 10, 2019

The Milwaukee and Chicago Civil War Round Tables have honored me by having me as their speaker May 9 (Milwaukee), and May 10 (Chicago).  I'll be discussing the little known battle of Jerusalem Plank Road, principally June 22, 1864, from the perspective of the 12th Virginia Infantry, the Petersburg Regiment.


Monday, April 8, 2019

Another Mystery about June 22-23, 1864: Activities of Bushrod Johnson's Division

On June 22, elements of Bushrod Johnson’s division moved out from behind Field’s and Kershaw’s divisions to the Johnson farm and remained in reserve behind Mahone’s troops as they prepared to roll up II Corps.  These elements included Wise’s Virginia Brigade and Ransom’s North Carolina Brigade minus its 49th North Carolina. Ransom’s brigade had received orders to relieve Colquitt’s brigade of Hoke’s division the previous day but after the 49th North Carolina relieved the pickets of Colquitt’s brigade, the rest of Ransom’s brigade got instructions to move out to the Johnson farm.[1]  Later, Bushrod Johnson's division advanced, then returned to the Johnson farm.

At least one source puts Bushrod Johnson's division under Hill's command.  Clark, North Carolina Regiments, 3:367.  If so, why didn't Hill let Mahone know?  It would have been easier for Mahone to draw upon Bushrod Johnson's uncommitted troops than try to get Wilcox's division to disengage from its action with VI Corps farther south.

On June 23, Elliott’s South Carolina Brigade of Bushrod Johnson’s division tramped out of reserve and joined Wise's brigade and Ransom's brigade (again minus the 49th North Carolina) of its division erecting breastworks on a north-south line on the eastern edge of the Johnson farm in case II Corps continued its advance westward.[2]


[1] Supplement to the OR, 7:278; OR 40, 1:761; Wiatt, Confederate Chaplain, 182.  Johnson’s Tennessee Brigade did not go out to the Johnson farm.  William Henry Harder Memoir, 525, Tennessee State Archives.  Nor did Elliott’s brigade, though it would the following day.  OR 40, 2:376.  Nor did all of Ransom’s Brigade.  OR 40, 2:678; Clark, North Carolina Regiments, 3:367; Diary of Captain Henry A. Chambers, 205.   



[2] Supplement 7:279; OR 40, 2:376; Wiatt, Confederate Chaplain, 182.

Sunday, March 31, 2019

More on Cadmus Wilcox

Major Edward Joseph Hale was the one who wrote to Brig. Gen. James Henry Lane on August 2, 1899 about the desire of Maj. Gen. Cadmus Marcellus Wilcox's other brigadiers (McGowan, Scales and Thomas) to court-martial Wilcox for cowardice for some action that seems to have occurred in the summer of 1864.  Hale wound up the war on Lane's staff and would have had the colonelcy of Lane's old regiment, the 28th North Carolina, but for not rising through its ranks--he began the war with the 1st North Carolina and rose through the 56th North Carolina. 

Bryce Suderow points out that General Lee appears to have punished Wilcox for his mishandling of his mission, to cooperate with Brig. Gen. William Mahone, on June 22, 1864.  On that day, Wilcox admittedly took about four or five  hours (from no later than 3:30 p.m until sundown around 7:30 p.m.) to move two or three miles.  (Wilcox Report on the Petersburg Campaign, Lee Headquarters Papers, Virginia Historical Society.)  The punishment was to strip Wilcox of troops.  "Two of my brigades were ordered to the north side of the James river to relieve two of Heth's, June 25th, McGowan & Lane," wrote Wilcox in his report on the Petersburg Campaign in the Lee Headquarters Papers in the Virginia Historical Society.  "July 4th, the remainder of the division, Scales and Thomas, were ordered to occupy from the Appomattox to Ashton Run," north of the Appomattox.  Not until August 24 did Wilcox get command of troops again.

Stripping troops from incompetent subordinates was one way Lee got rid of them.  After Brig. Gen. Roger Atkinson Pryor mishandled Anderson's division at Sharpsburg, Lee stripped him of troops by breaking up his brigade and assigning its regiments elsewhere.  Pryor got the message and resigned the following year.

Pryor was only a pre-war newspaperman and politician.  Wilcox was a West Pointer, not as easily abandoned.  Likewise, a court-martial for cowardice seems a bit extreme for mere incompetence, especially when everyone but Mahone shared that attribute moving around in the veritable jungle south of Petersburg.  In the country of the blind, the one-eyed man is king, and south of Petersburg, Mahone (a former railroad engineer who had surveyed much of the ground) was the guy with one eye.

Monday, March 25, 2019

Wilcox's Brigadiers Wanted Him Court-Martialed for Cowardice

It recently came to my attention that three of Maj. Gen. Cadmus Wilcox's brigadiers (Scales, Thomas and McGowan) wanted Wilcox court-martialed for cowardice (!) during the summer of 1864, looks like before Second Reams Station.  Letter, E. J. Hale to Lane, August 2, 1899.  I'm grateful to Russ Edwards and Bryce Suderow for this information.  I'll be looking into this further and will report on it as more light is shed.  Please feel free to pass on any information you have about this to me at johnedwardhorn@gmail.com

Saturday, March 16, 2019

12th Virginia Infantry, Small World Department

Charles David "Charley" Blanks was born in Petersburg, Virginia in September 1842.  https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/154717152/charles-david-blanks   No official record ties him to the 12th Virginia Infantry, C.S.A., also known as "the Petersburg Regiment."  He did not join the regiment while the official records that have survived were being generated.  The only information that ties him to the 12th is that Private Blanks and First Lt. Allen Washington Magee laid down their arms at Appomattox with the regiment's Company C, the Petersburg New or B Grays, after returning from furloughs, and that they did not receive paroles.  Our source for this information is an undated letter by Magee that is reprinted on pages 322-324 of the Appendix of George S. Bernard's War Talks of Confederate Veterans (Petersburg, Va.:  Fenn & Owen, 1892).

Charley was the son of Henry A. Blanks, who died in Petersburg June 10, 1864, of wounds sustained the previous day in the previous day's Battle of Old Men and Young Boys.  Charley's mother was Ann Eliza Fisher Banks, 1816-1888.  Charley's elder brother was Pvt. Henry A. Blanks, Jr., a carpenter born in 1840 who enlisted in the Petersburg City Guard April 19, 1861, and was killed in action at Malvern Hill July 1, 1862.  Charley's first wife was Louisa J. Blanks, born in Nottoway County in 1841 and married in Petersburg December 7, 1865.  She died in Petersburg March 29, 1875, after the birth of Charley's son Charles B. Blanks on March 12, 1875, who died in Petersburg June 27, 1875.  Henry, Ann, Henry, Jr., Louisa and Charles B. all lie in Petersburg's Blandford Cemetery.

In the following year, Charley married Sarah J. Rowan Blanks, born in Richmond in 1856.  By 1912, he lived in Chicago.  His wife died in Chicago on June 25 of that year and was buried in Chicago's Rosehill Cemetery and Mausoleum in Chicago.  

By 1916, Charley was living in Oak Forest, Illinois.  He died there June 14, 1916.  He lies in Tinley Park, Illinois' Tinley Park Memorial Cemetery.

Charley is special for me because I live in Oak Forest, my law office is in Tinley Park, and I am one of the historians of his regiment.

It's a small world.