Friday, March 6, 2020

The Double Disaster of Maj. Gen. Henry Wager Halleck's 1862 Appointment as Federal General-in-Chief


From Miller’s Vicksburg I principally took away that Maj. Gen. Henry Wager “Old Brains” Halleck failed to provide troops to assist the Navy in capturing Vicksburg before the Confederates could man and fortify that city.  “Old Brains” thus set back the Union war effort a year in the West.

I already knew that Halleck helped set back the Federal war effort two years in the East.  Historians are fond of quoting General Robert Edward Lee’s reported remark that once the Federals reached James River, it was only a matter of time (till Richmond fell).  But the Federals had reached James River by July 1862, and they did not return for another two years because Halleck ordered them back to Washington in response to the threat Lee posed to the city.  One must sympathize a little with “Old Brains” because Maj. Gen. George Brinton McClellan was not the man to advance from Harrison’s Landing and a suitable replacement for him could not be found.  The Unionists may have had to cross the James to Bermuda Hundred or City Point to find a rail network capable of supporting another advance on Richmond.     

The Northerners faced a situation similar to July 1862 in August 1864.  Lee was gradually shifting his forces northward to threaten Washington as in August 1862, but this time he faced Lt. Gen. Ulysses Simpson Grant, not Halleck.  Grant on August 14, 1864 launched his fourth offensive at Petersburg with a thrust toward Richmond which ended Lee’s shift northward and forced him to recall a cavalry division en route to northern Virginia.  The Federals were on James River to stay.


No comments:

Post a Comment